Secret Santa 2024
real good but
on the right side of the tail is kinda flat,
and i think the horns look good but they dont really blend

but overall really good
Your shading seems to constantly be a bit off, not following the outline. The shading on the head makes it look like a ball cut in half with eyes and horns on top. The tail's shading is just plain right off, it makes no sense, try making it actually go parallel to the outlines of the tail.
Thanks for the comments and Mapleleaf the shading I know is off but it was too late to change it when I adjusted it to pixel size
the curves are not aesthetically pleasing.

and neither is your attempt at making the holes 3d D:

however, the idea is good. keep working on this, and it will become something good.
Former Item Forger