Yeah these are some of my first sigs (I made 4).
I won't post the stocks / Renders because they are like 3000 x 4000 (I won't bother posting them)

Latest one 1.

2.

3.

4.

I really like it.
And where is the 4? :P

Nice work you did here, and you just started making siggys?
Looks like you've been making em for a longer time[ which means you are really good at what you do].
Hoping to see more soon.

The 4th one is in the other thread. Thanks.

Yeah I just started.

nice work bro i rly like it you get better and better 10/10

good as first signatures ^^

some tips for you:
1) try making a better merging of the render with the background... just apply the image in a new layer... add an effect, edit the layer proprieties and delete the parts of the main part of the render...
2) you already saw a method to make a border... but just make a grey border and change the layer proprieties (like lighten or dodge)
3)work on the bg.. try making it not too empty (like second) and not too full
4) use good looking effects... and try adding some flow...
5) follow gfx experts guides, they teach alot!!!

great work qusay ;p i love the quality of the sigs. i like the second sig the most and the rest are good too. keep it up.

I like This much.
But the Red Lines on his hand is too "Round"

Is Like the god of war one best also.
And the borders on these are great but maybe you should just go simple on these borders.
Like a simple black line always works.
And i also think you put the god of war person in the wronge place.
it looks sorta better with the guy at the side of the sig. Like in your second one.
But your blur effect is nice and the red ray around the arm is great.
Keep it up.

But imo , the positioning is perfect. What's wrong ?