Original Post
Wolf's replay thread!
Im trying to make a permanent replay thread. So please help by rating and discussing...
My first madman. Well sorta madman.
My first madman. Well sorta madman.
sloppy, thats's the only word i can really find to describe that replay. just because a replay's a madman doesn't automatially make it goo. it had very little flow, the opener was wierd and the only hit i actually like was the last one. u need to work on improving ur flow, grab less and try to be cleaner with ur hits 4/10
[Pure], wanna join?
Originally Posted by Nyster
Wolf257: I don't know who you are, but I can tell you that weed has no idea what she (or he, probably not) is talking about. She said grab less, but you had one moment where you grabbed for one set of turn frames. Grabbing less is not grabbing at all, so that was wrong and horribly opinionative criticism. Also he says more flow? Your quite relaxed if I could say so. You can't make a madman where the player dismembers many uke parts if you have 'flow' like he is thinking. If you had a madman with flow like in his thoughts, you would be making a tornado movement, where you moved in one clockwise or counterclockwise direction the whole game unless you SLOWLY moved the opposite way at a period of time. Last, "the opener is weird is the suckiest point a critique can give". Critiquing something is explaining what is right or wrong with it. I say it was quite impressive.
Same with your 2nd replay.
9/10 nice job.
okay maybe i was a little harsh, but i still stick with my opinion. but thats not the point, u can't just flame someone for their opinion. that's just being an asshole. and u can have flow in madman's to a certain extent, he was constantly changing how he was moving this can sometimes look good but he overused it and the replay ended up looking broken.
Originally Posted by Wolf257
Wow thanks,,, Btw, Have you ever heard of 'constructive critisism'?
i believe it was constructive criticism, i didn't just say "i didn't like it 4/10" i said why i didn't like and told u how to improve it. okay as i said before maybe i could've been a bit nicer i suppose
i like ur other replays considerably more than ur first, although they were just decaps and so their is a limit to good they can be unless they're absolutely amazing decaps, however they weren't they were kinda average 6.5/10 both
[Pure], wanna join?
