This thread is the reason I try to stay away from anime threads.
Most of you guys are suggesting entry-level stuff. Everyone and their grandmother has seen most of this stuff.

I recommend
Kaiji
Aria
Haibane Renmei
Nanoha A's
Card Captor Sakura

That seems to spread across a few different genres. All you listed was generic shonenshit.

Also,
Watch to the end of the Soul Society arc(around episode 60). After that it turns to shit.

especially the boring one that rittu posted

Some suggestions I agreed with(Including yours). Hence why I said most.

Also, that comment about generic shonenshit was directed at the first post. My mistake if I didn't make that clear.