Attached is a screenshot of what my "Toribash" folder looks like. I downloaded 3.41, and replaced the default replays with my own. I trashed the old Toribash folder, started playing, logged in, and then looked for my replays.

They're all in the game, but strangely they are nowhere to be found in the folder. Neither is the actual Toribash game. I'd reinstall but I'm afraid I would lose all my replays, since they apparently don't exist (But somehow appear in game).

I checked, and I'm sure I'm using the correct version. As you can see, all my replays are in there with the new version(attached), but they don't appear in the folder.

So it seems I have imaginary replays and an imaginary Toribash?

Whats your OS?

mac i think..am i correct?

He's using a mac, yes.

Mac OSX Tiger. Still haven't gotten around to getting Leopard.

I think thats your problem
the game can only handle the
"higher" versions of osx now

^^^please correct me if i am wrong