Why do people think they can get away unflamed with symmetrical replays just because they (say they) are noobs? Especially if they say that the replays are probably noobish? You don't post bad replays. There's no use for them and they're so alike (symmetry) that someone else has with a high possibility posted almost the same thing before.
Read the forums a bit, find out what the norm is (how good the replays are when they start getting positive feedback, and that they are never still symmetrical at that point), achieve that norm and only then start posting your replays
sheesh...