so, here's the deal

why shouldn't there be an option to see who exactly downloaded an attachment?

i'm pretty curious about who looks at my replays and this way proving someone stole/didn't steal a replay will be at least a bit easier

Well they can just go into their downloaded files and delete the downloaded replay file

if this was implemented i would assume it would track what account was logged in when said replay was downloaded, however if i didn't want you knowing i am downloading your replay all i have to do is log out, download the replay and log right back in. The system would see a guest is downloading the replay and not a signed in player, it's so simple to avoid it's not even worth implementing.

i don't think you can download replays while logged out

but if you can they can just remove the option

waifu is right i just checked myself never knew that, in that case then there is no real way to avoid having your name (or at least one of your names) tracked.

You could make a fake a account just to download it......

Staffs can see all of your alts

Why would it even matter. Replay stealing isn't illegal, staff don't need to be assed about tracking down the player who stole a replay.

Taking other people's replays for your own personal use is fine, but what if there was a replay event and I stole one of Shiro's (EPIC) replays and submitted it as my own replay. That is illegal my friend and if Shiro's suggestion was implemented then it would be just that much easier to frame people for these thefts.

Keep in mind we're not talking about regular replays here, we're talking about replays from people that almost only play in Single player, dedicating their time on Toribash to perfecting these said replays, a lot of hours and effort goes into these replays. Replays such as Shiro's classify as Art just like textures do and I know if someone stole the textures you owned and used them you would be pissed and report them. For textures its easier to prove they are your's, though for replays it tends to be a bit harder.

I Support Shiro's idea.

that doesn't really matter

ips are traceable anyway