Originally Posted by
TyZi
The game isn't really dying, and I don't think any of this is necessary or worth implementing.
I'm not sure how you can say that in good conscience.
Assuming that the community ISN'T dying,, there are at best around 3000-4000 players. Pretty small community, either way. This kind of stuff wouldn't hurt that.
Originally Posted by
TyZi
Almost everyone is directed to the forums when they're ingame at some point, where everything is.
You took care to use words like "almost" and "at some point" so you're still technically correct, but you pass it off like it's helping your argument...
No, it can take new players a very long time to figure out where the forums are. I didn't figure out the forums existed until I was almost 2nd dan, and that's a lot of missed time, ESPECIALLY during the time critical to new players.
There's a huge learning curve for toribash, and if you quit you'll probably quit pretty early - while you're still trying to learn to play the game. However, there are a lot of resources on the forums that can help you learn, as well as a whole different side of the community that could keep new players rooted here. I think making the forums a little more obvious for players starting out would be a fantastic idea.
Originally Posted by
Fear
The idea of a launcher (similar to league or something) is ideal to be honest.
TB survives on its community yet the game offers no redirection to the forums at all; anything like that has to come from the existing community.
The tutorials are so-so in my opinion: making the introduction to the game nicer is obviously a good step and I support this notion entirely, but I don't think it would have the same impact a decent launcher/client would have.
The youtuber idea is maybe idealistic.
Point 4 is exploitable.
Point 5 is whatever. Feels like it might give people less reason to explore outside the client if you see what I mean.
I pretty much agree with everything here, except I'd be a little bit more enthusiastic about tutorials. I know a lot of people say that the only way you can learn is simply by playing the game, and I think they're 100% dead wrong. There are so many different things you could tell new players about joint configurations, applications and situations you use certain joints, and little tips and tricks. Especially so with newer players.
I'll bring up an example from outside TB.
I've been playing the classical guitar for almost three years. I'm largely self taught (as far as fingerstyle goes), although I did take regular instruction for the electric/acoustic guitar for a few years beforehand.
Now about 8 months ago, I started to look for more resources to help me learn. Looking back, I was pretty much garbage at the time (relative to how I am now). My left hand technique was sloppy (heck, my picking hand was sloppy too), and I was super duper slow and limited with how I was picking. Well, when I started watching instruction videos and asking for help, I picked up a lot of fun little tricks. I learned to change my posture, which has helped tremendously. I learned how to properly hold my left hand (fretting) to allow for wrist movement and ease for fretting on a wider fretboard. I learned a neat little picking trick that allows me to play almost twice as fast.
TL; DR - I was trash while I was self taught, and now that I've gotten help and instruction I'm actually pretty good.
So yeah. Better tutorials would be cool. For example:
http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=547666
http://forum.toribash.com/showpost.p...1&postcount=10
K0HTA is an egotistical dip so he closed the first one before he could get any feedback on the idea or elaborations, but I think the base idea is pretty cool regardless.
Last edited by Scissor414; Feb 8, 2016 at 10:53 PM.