First of all, i'm very bad at commenting and i'm very bad at madmans so i have absolutely no idea why i'm commenting this but since you asked so nice with triple posts and all and have a nice avatar, i thought i'd still post this.

Your first madman - I liked it but not that much
Your second madman - I didn't like it that much either and i think you're supposed to also get the hand
Your third madman - I liked it but i didn't like how you almost grabbed him nonstop from one position the entire replay.
Your fourth madman - I like replays where you don't touch uke so much from everywhere as if you want to hug him, the start was nice but then it got worse. Also you ghosted, -points for that.
Your fifth madman - Oooo, deffinetly better than the ones before this, i really enjoyed this one ^^. And you're good at posing also.
Your sixth madman - It started off not so good but when you got to dismembering uke, it was great. Was the first kick ment to push uke up and not dismember?
Your seventh madman - wasn't as clean as i'd like it to be but i could never do a replay like that so it was also good : D. And you did some ghosting there at like 314'th frame.
Your eigth madman - First i thought.. Insta 10 points for no grab! But when i watched the first 60 frames, i felt like taking like 3 points off because it was indeed very stiff. But then i unpaused it and when the replay was finished, i felt like giving 2 points back. 9/10!

---

Altogether, i don't want the 30 minutes i wasted watching and commenting back.