1/10 way too grabby, way too slow and too sloppy
here are a few tips:
good replay makers frequently use the core joints to power their kicks, punches ..etc...
and only use the limbs to aim and tweak the hit.
dont grab for the whole replay, only grab when you can make a boom if possible.
i like to see replays with atleast a cap n' split.
style: add little details to your movements to give it a sense of uniqueness
finesse: i like movements to flow well, use relax and style to your advantage
cleanliness: too much bruising ( when bodyparts glow red due to contact) is very unattractive
LONG LIVE GOOD REPLAYS