Secret Santa 2024
Originally Posted by Redundant View Post
Meh, this is a typical example of people going for the profit no matter what.
Farmers could easily improve the animal's life by spending more money on more human methods.
Meat would probably become a little more expensive on the long run.
Since we live in a capitalistic system competition needs to be beaten even if that means that some animals suffer
They do not desire to make their life better and rather maximize the profit.



…wat?
Hunted by cows and birds?

If anything it is
Profit, or more profit.

Basically trying to get at the fact that if we didn't fight to sustain life on Earth by fighting, hunting, and killing, we would all die. Though I disagree with what I said, and I would have to agree with what you said.
And? Don't like it, don't eat it.

I personally could not care less, yes, it could be more humane, however, it is human life. All things strive to live, it is necessary to kill to survive. Death is the absence of life and death is necessary for life to occur.

Remember, this same exact stuff happened to living human beings over history (only more painful because humans experience feeling in greater volume than most animals), from the Gulag, to the Extermination camps of the SS, to Vlad the Impaler's dungeon. Shit happens, it just depends on how we deal with it. Don't let your frail sensitivities get in the way of things, if it happens, it happens, besides that, this was a very negative video towards the meat industry, and I doubt it shows both sides, and probably went out of their way to find instances of inhumanity towards animals.

Again, if you don't like it, don't eat it.
Originally Posted by Gorman View Post
Be the good guy and play devil's advocate, more or less? @_@

Ok sure, if you say so!



I think that this kind of thing is completely acceptable. Firstly because we are the dominant species in this world, we can and should do whatever we find culturally acceptable. We need our beef, and this is the easiest way to get it. I don't see anything wrong with that.

Besides that, what does it matter if some dumb animal feels some pain in the moments before it's death? The workers obviously don't care, so why should we? They only reason that someone would say "oh this is so bad and unacceptable" is because they are ignorant. This goes on a hundred thousand times a day, every day, in every country.

I could guilt trip you every day of the week, about much more meaningful stuff (deforestation of rain-forests just so you can get your toilet paper huh? pollution of oceans and rivers from your soap? etc etc), but the bottom line is no one really cares.

People as a whole do not care about this meaningless shit, they just want their big mac.

I salute you sir, you hit the nail on the head. The only thing I'm really worried about is the sored meat, I don't want to happen to be the unlucky one to eat that. Besides the point, mmm... big macs. ;o

Originally Posted by Fishies View Post
Just watching the first ten seconds make me shudder. Espeicially when they showed the pigs mouth. Thats when I exited.

What has the world come to?

Boohoo. The world has always been this way, survival of the fittest. Also, the video wasn't that bad.

Hit that chicken with the crowbar again, farmer man!

EDIT: Sorry, had to bring this up. I just saw that part of the video where the guy was owning a cow in the face and then body slamming it. I couldn't help but laugh a little.. It reminds me of punching babies, except in calf form.
Last edited by Mookiefish; May 3, 2011 at 06:04 AM.
Not giving a fuck about hurricanes is pretty badass - Fee


#ItemRights!
Originally Posted by Romanovsky View Post
And? Don't like it, don't eat it.

I personally could not care less, yes, it could be more humane, however, it is human life. All things strive to live, it is necessary to kill to survive. Death is the absence of life and death is necessary for life to occur.

Remember, this same exact stuff happened to living human beings over history (only more painful because humans experience feeling in greater volume than most animals), from the Gulag, to the Extermination camps of the SS, to Vlad the Impaler's dungeon. Shit happens, it just depends on how we deal with it. Don't let your frail sensitivities get in the way of things, if it happens, it happens, besides that, this was a very negative video towards the meat industry, and I doubt it shows both sides, and probably went out of their way to find instances of inhumanity towards animals.

Again, if you don't like it, don't eat it.

It is not a question of decision but a question of ethics.
A government could easily pass laws that prohibit cruelty like that.
The production would be a little more expensive, but that is a minor side effect that the market will adapt and get used to.

Originally Posted by Mookiefish View Post
I salute you sir, you hit the nail on the head. The only thing I'm really worried about is the sored meat, I don't want to happen to be the unlucky one to eat that. Besides the point, mmm... big macs. ;o



Boohoo. The world has always been this way, survival of the fittest. Also, the video wasn't that bad.

Hit that chicken with the crowbar again, farmer man!

EDIT: Sorry, had to bring this up. I just saw that part of the video where the guy was owning a cow in the face and then body slamming it. I couldn't help but laugh a little.. It reminds me of punching babies, except in calf form.

Not sure if you are trolling.
We are in a sophisticated society, we don't need to fight the creatures we eat and keep them down or anything . :|
There is a point when too much is too much.
Last edited by Redundant; May 3, 2011 at 06:06 AM.
How are you?
Personally, I'm not against slaughter houses. We eat meat, so we get meat.

Sure, there are certain things that could be improved, but if that's the way they choose to go about it, then so be it. I'd say that if any un-needed suffering could be taken away (without lowering efficiency) then that would be nice.

To show my views backing up those opinions, I view rational agents above all else. (This may not mean humans are on top, but which ever creature is a better rational agent. Meaning that an intelligent primate would be held above a mentally challenged human.)

I'd agree with those who are saying "If you don't like it, don't eat it." (Gormon et. al.)
-- Jet -- Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known. --
[Secret]AikidoKP

Cogito ergo sum. I think therefor I exist.

I know it's true because it says so right here in this signature.
Originally Posted by Redundant View Post
It is not a question of decision but a question of ethics.
A government could easily pass laws that prohibit cruelty like that.
The production would be a little more expensive, but that is a minor side effect that the market will adapt and get used to.


Not sure if you are trolling.
We are in a sophisticated society, we don't need to fight the creatures we eat and keep them down or anything . :|
There is a point when too much is too much.

Do you live for disagreeing with common sense?

I thought your problem was with sophisticated society and the 'inhumane' brutality of a slaughter house. I thought you wanted to go back to spears and shields against animals that have a large chance of killing you. My bad. Your points confuse.
The only discussion going on here is "animal abuse is okay because we don't care," replied to with "you're stupid and heartless," etc.

There's no justification for animal abuse, and neither is there any point in remaking this topic 3 times.

edit: mookiefish is a troll and needs to be removed from local mod already.
Buy TC for a great price here! http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=240345
Buy VIP and Toriprime for a great price here! http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=237249


Hey look more than two lines.
This isn't animal abuse, chickens are mentally retarded creatures by nature. Pigs are fatasses that would probably only die on their own for what they are worth. Cows... what do they live for? Eating grass. Indeed.

Animal abuse would be abusing an animal that DIDN'T end up in a big mac/bacon strip/chicken tender.
Originally Posted by Romanovsky View Post
This isn't animal abuse, chickens are mentally retarded creatures by nature.

I'm pretty sure they're still animals.
Originally Posted by Romanovsky
Pigs are fatasses that would probably only die on their own for what they are worth.

And they came into existence and thrived purely because humanity made it so.
Also, as fat is defined per species, only the especially heavy pigs can be defined as fatasses.
Originally Posted by Romanovsky
Cows... what do they live for? Eating grass. Indeed.

Right, this totally justifies causing them extreme harm.

Originally Posted by Romanovsky
Animal abuse would be abusing an animal that DIDN'T end up in a big mac/bacon strip/chicken tender.

Remind me to come to you on your death bed and horribly beat you. You're going to die soon anyways, right?


Since when was discussion a shitting ground for wibble trolls?
Buy TC for a great price here! http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=240345
Buy VIP and Toriprime for a great price here! http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=237249


Hey look more than two lines.