Secret Santa 2024
Alright, there's a lot to comment on, so don't expect too much feedback on every replay. I'll say something positive, something negative, and grade it, that's all.

@LT
Boxing 77077--> I like how you used the ropes, I didn't like it that you fell at the end. 8/10
kickbos irman--> I like the elbow of doom, I didn't like the decap. 7/10
kickbos 4 jisse fly--> I like your tactical retreat, I didn't like you ripping your own elbow off. 5/10
len Huskai--> I like how you sort of tackled him, I didn't like it that your grip split him. 7.4/10
len pitch--> I like the way you blocked his kick at the start, I didn't like it that you headbutted his arm off. 6.8/10
pk pitchah wallfail--> I like the backflip on the ledge, I didn't like the stiffness with which you sat on top of the wall. 7.8/10
zwei fanty--> I like the screenshot I took from behind you at frame 14, and I suggest you do that too, it looks awesome. Nice decap, and good job stealing mah sword :L. 9/10

@TRichard
ninja man--> I like the horizontal spins, I didn't like the frontflip, it looked unrealistic to me, and the way you continued the landing could've been better as well. 7.9/10
obazu spar--> I like the "die potato", I didn't like the length of the replay :L. Also, why is it named "obazu spar" when you're fighting uke? 6/10
shortspar sicmo--> I liked the flip near the end, I didn't like the kick at frame 240-ish. 7/10
Rob Staff spar--> I loved the way Uke/rob handled the staff, I didn't like the way you hit yourself on the head near the end.
latin cage--> I like the final kick you did, I didn't see any flaws or something. But I'm sure there's room for improvements. 9/10
very long vault--> Yes, that was a very long vault. It looked realistic. 9/10
dojo fight-->I like the way Uke throws you into the wall, I didn't like it how Uke was just standing there taking hits at the start. 8/10
spar subzeroz--> I like how you smacked him in the face as he said "don't you jump at me", I didn't like the spazzy jump at the beginning.
sword skills--> I like the dodges and the way you knocked him out. I don't really see any bad things in this. 9/10
tricks kicks--> I like the second and third kick, as well as the sort of heli kick, I didn't like the first one though. 7/10
long vault--> Hmmm this can be divided into 2 semi-long vaults.I like the first part, to the center beam-thing, I didn't like the 2nd part, your arm seemed to be stiff :O
6/10
I hope I didn't forget any replays...

Now finally: my replay!!!
Worked 2 days on this one, in my opinion, it's my best madman so far
Attached Files
Fantyful - Despair.rpl (425.4 KB, 12 views)
Last edited by fantyful; Aug 2, 2013 at 11:26 PM.
Fantyful - It was a nice replay in my opinion, there were only a few doubts I had with it. The opener seemed a little out of the ordinary, and a bit uncoordinated, I would have suggested a bit more of a well thought through opener for such a Madman. The other doubt wasn't much of a big deal but I felt that your knees were contracted a bit too much during the replay, looked like you were just flying around and picking up severed limbs and chucking them around. But other than than that, it was a nice replay over all, good flow, kept the replay going, you were thinking outside of the box with some of the moves which I like, I rate it 7/10


I only have two replays to post here today, one single player and one Multiplayer.

The single player replays is some sort of slow Madman, I don't really do Sp replays often so this is just some couple of kicks thrown together.
Attached Files
mp_kb destruction.rpl (66.0 KB, 6 views)
Originally Posted by 2pro4you View Post
monkey.. Read our rules again and think what went wrong?

I think it's just easier to tell him. Monkey, you have to give constructive criticism of the replay(s) above you.
Lynx.
Aquatic Stimulation.
The starting jump was nice but it feel like it would look better in a -30.00 gravity match.
I didn't like the way you touched Uke during the split, it lacked power. The upcoming kick was good as well, but you should have edited in atleast another dm. The third kick hit using the ankle which looked odd. The last dm didn't really belong due to it being so late. A skeet would've looked better in that situation.
Good replay!

MP_KB destruction
Very fast paced replay. To bad you didn't get a dm with the first kick. I really enjoyed the last leg dm.

My best selfspar, so far.
Attached Files
Jisse - Slender.rpl (443.6 KB, 8 views)
Jisse - That was pretty cool lol . The first set of punches was really nice , the whole arm swing strikes were like somthing out of a kungfu film . I did not expect the choke hold with uke's legs squirming wich was great . I can see any flaws except for the legs being alittle too straight .

9/10



Now here is a fun run with me and Lordtiger , if you have not seen any of our replays , we tend to have alot of fun with them and go where we want to . Im the one that flips to the bottom first , this replay is alittle weird . Maybe its just me .


Edit by LT: Aw shucks, I wanted to upload that Good times. I had to replace the replay with the one I saved, because yours was corrupted(seemed like you and a dude from another clan made it). Hopefully mine's not corrupted.

Attached Files
trichard LT run final.rpl (1.27 MB, 13 views)
Last edited by lordtiger; Sep 17, 2012 at 12:25 AM.
Lol that kinda made me laughe, i liked the realistic fall and when u were climbimg down the wall there. Problem with me is i cant keep on running once ive stopped, so im not the best in parkours n stuff.

Anyways: this is the first move of a replay i comleted, but want to start over with this opener.
Im actualy kinda stuck here i dont realy know how to make the next clean dm.

Yes yes im not a total member yet but just could not wate to show this, but what ever here it is.
Attached Files
Pancakes_yes _yes#1.rpl (180.8 KB, 13 views)
Last edited by shrimp24; Sep 24, 2012 at 10:41 PM.
[Hunters]
IMO the replay was really sloppy and had quite a bit of useless movement in it, unless you were trying to go for a non realistic replay...

(Is not good with C&C)

Here is my self spar.

Rawb vs Bawbb.rpl