I'm still in favor of monster duck. Add wounds,and have it beat up, just like our current status.

But make it jacked.

photoshop some 300-eske abs onto it

yellow small-ish duck, or an adult duck? also colors n stuff, white or wat?

A large yellow duck.

war vet looking duck would be great

I'll start working on it, though can't promise much(I suck at drawning for now).
So if there's someone else interested in it as well, he should do it, and we will choose the better one in the end.

I can try I guess.

if everything has to be hand drawn, it may be tough, but I am meh at editing pictures, so hopefully I can make it look nice if I can.

Maybe someone should make a sketch of it, someone else would take that sketch, and add details and stuff, and another person add color, texture, etc.

has to be done by 1 person afaik.

Ahh, you're right. Should stop skimming through the rules