Fail, because the community is biased and full of noobs who will get all their noob friends to vote badly for a clan just because they don't like or they have a personal grudge. I think the actual test should become harder- I.E, more members needed, or maybe 100k needed instead of 50. As far as the admins voting, well MBK has to sort through each clan before they become official, you don't hand Mr.Pringle 50k and become official immediately.