I say no to BowlerHats. (unless I can be convinced ingame or irc)
I've seen this type one too many times, and I feel he won't have much to bring to this clan from what I can see. I hate judging off of "good" apps and first impressions though. I feel it just doesn't hold any weight in my acceptance decisions. So for now I will give a no, until I can get to know him more over time and properly gauge his aptitude.