hmm, well, so far, i havent seen any real screamers on the games, i dont want there to be screamers like every second, but once in the hour :P i spoke with my friend and he said that penumbra is scarier... (also, i dont like monsters like flaming and shit, i want it mostly zombies xd) also, i've tried all doom, and wtf, they rnt scary, kinda fun... but it's not scary. and dead space, i've tried it, and it seems kinda scary, but... it's... weird... also, im home alone and im will play on the night, so penumbra should make you fear your own life not the game and fear 2 will make me spasm once in a while?

Don't play either of them. The scariest game by far is Resident Evil 5 with Dead space like right behind it.

lol, resident evil isnt scary... >.<' and deadspace is... GUH!

Definitely Penumbra. F.E.A.R. is fun, but Penumbra is more thrilling and scary.

Dude, definitely Penumbra- you start the gaming screaming for help and you ill finish screaming when u reach the end of the game. Im currently playing Penumbra: The Black Plague, and i simply cant stop its addictive. When u discover how to solve a puzzle u have another one waiting u in the next door. Its the scariest game i ever played. If you really want to get scared, play penumbra ;)

F.E.A.R is just an FPS with 4/5 scary moments. While on Penumbra fear becomes part of your life.

FEAR isn't really 'scary'.

All it is is some bitch getting close to you, but never really doing anything bad. The only way it could actually be scary is for you to be him, then maybe.

But I would think Dead Space is pretty scary, never played that though.

ok, now i've played FEAR2 about 30-40% of the game and about 20 min of penumbra black plague, penumbra was WAAAAAAY scarier, fear2... the only thing u get scared by is when some random flaming uber monster pops up behind u screaming like hell, but in penumbra ur scared about 70-80% of the time.

so, trough my opinion: fear2 = fun fps game... ... dead space = kinda like gow2 but... more weird .... resident evil = fun as hell .... penumbra = play it at midnight woithout any lights on and you will shit a building in your pants.

fatal frame

its a horror game

trust me on this one.

unfortunately i dont think its on computer

Use an emulator for fatal frame.
But yeah, Penumbra is WAYYYY scarier...

I played penumbra 2 days ago, and i haven't gotten a minute of sleep.