Why not just make it two sections? A replay board dedicated to ownage and one for everyone else. That way there can be whatever number of people and it'll seem less crowded. With all those stickies people'll be even less likely to read the rules.

I chose two and three, but I still think we should just integrate the already in place voting system into the main board somehow. Its a totally useless tab at the top of the screen, and it had good potential.

Also, you suck suo.

Go for Democracy.

If democracy wins.

You should be able to add people to that best of thingy after time. There are so many good replay makers most probably won't make it.

I Agree with splinter.

Is the list gonna be updated?
like a comp, 3best replays of the month goes in to this list or something ?
Or you find something out so new ppl can make the list and get famous. oooOOOOoo

btw: Democracy and this is an awsome idea

I have an idea that I think is good, but I don't think the way the forum works allows this. What if every thread where the last post had an attachment ( so an unrated replay on this board ) and is under about 2,3 days old would be stickied. It would be unstickied when there are comments, but will be stickied again. That's all possible, but the question was "Could that be automated?" or else the local mods would be very busy, that's not really useful.

PART 3!

for some reason i dont think this is all to fair because people will begin to only look at the pros replays and the noobier replays arent going to get any comments or crittisizim... so go wiith make a sub forum for the pros....
p.s. dont kill me

There already is: ORMO

..........oh thats what that is.... okay never mind then go with democorcy.