seeing from now,
you made shading with black and white, it is a big mistake,
the overall look is worse.
About result,
the torso and arms are with a lower contrast than it should be,
we cannot see an arms and the back, it is the same.
That is the meaning of flat.
I see a good result with the torso texture,
seems really like skin.
The head had a great result,
I see the bends,
altought the tongue fell into
same mistake said about shading.