That's why I don't exactly want to rate these videos.
If you're just slapping effects on, then it's not really editing. I mean, if you actually made the effect then that's different.

Indeed.
I try to avoid threads with those videos but sometimes content of bullshit is just too high to ignore .-.

I wanna see your perfect artistic toribash video works Powas.
Also, what's the problem with an over edited video? Why should it have to be bad?
What's the problem :l

His channel is powas92 i think, rofl.
Problem is that every video is overedited now.

Love what you did with the sun on the 3rd replay <3
The effects didn't obscure the replays too much, the sync was spot on, and the video was entertaining. (imo)

I can't really find anything wrong with this video...
I guess, you can maybe move the camera around a little more on parts like 0:08.
Short videos don't bother me at all, but I think making videos that are at least 50 - 60 seconds long might satisfy the community more.

Great job ;)

We're not talking about mine videomaking skills and if you think someone needs to be perfect videomaker to c&c then gg.

Anyway, my opinion about this kind of videos is pretty much in this thread: http://forum.toribash.com/showthread.php?t=345125

If you want to discuss more, pm me.

Not bad

[pl] może w końcu zrobisz coś dłuższego np z 2 min?[pl]

Ok I understood your point Powas, they should make some awesome videos like this but more longer... all of us want that

Just throwing myself into the overediting discussion here, I had to watch it 4 times before I knew what was going on. I watch toribash videos to watch toribash videos, not a clusterfuck of effects thrown in.

Sorry if I come over as offensive, but you overspammed it so there was so much going on I couldn't focus myself anywhere.

WRONG.
They should make some awesome videos, but totally not like this.
Yes, short lenght of those videos is a big issue, tho not a main one.
Main is overediting with PREMADE effect templates like those from cc series. Creating a video like this, with usage of those premades is a matter of 20 minutes.
Anyway, point of creating toribash video is to show gameplay, replays, inspire others to play and vidoes like this above are like - 'hey I know how to use premade templates, set keyframes, record replays, add music and render it all!'. Totally not a something I want to watch, nor I want toribash videos to be.

No, just no.

Example how good tb vid should look like (a.k.a my personal top 3)







There are many more great vids (colours, overkill, warcry's olda, verax's works etc), I just don't want to make this post wall of videos.