Originally Posted by
Zking
If you remove greed, lust, ambition, negative emotion and fear from the equation, while giving society a set of guidelines, they wouldn't be failures since they would be obedient, tranquil, and intelligent. Some sort of industrialist socialist empire would form and proto-humanity would reach the stars.
-----
An attitude shift towards what? Consumerism? Capitalism is built off the exploitation and corruption of the human condition, i.e a prison with invisible walls. There will never be a perfect world with the current system. I don't see how communism (see: world peace) would be "un-necessary" either.
Assuming that emotions and motivations are as clear cut as you seem to imply they are (which we cannot prove as of now) and that it's even possible to cull specific emotions without influencing related emotions (lust and love are just varying degrees of attraction), the "remove emotions, insert obedience" reeks of authoritarianism.
I'm all for human augmentation, there's nothing wrong with prosthetics or externalization of human function, but augmentation is not the same as modification. It's one thing to make a better eye, or a better arm, or a faster brain, this is just enhancing that which is already present. But modification is a judgement call on what is superior and inferior, and with something as complicated as our mind, it is ludicrous to make assumptions on what is superior for the advancement of humanity.
And let's not get into theoretical, perfect world arguments if you're not going to apply the same scenario to the other side. In a perfect world, capitalism is the harnessing the resources of society to meet the greatest demands of society and delivering them efficiently to society at little cost because of competition. In practice, attempts at capitalism create a massive imbalance of power between haves and have-nots. In a perfect world, communism is the harnessing of the resources of the society to fulfill the needs of society. In practice, attempts at communism create the same imbalance of power that capitalism creates.