So I will pass over and only take the constructive cristicism.
About the overlay, it is too opaque and reduces color correction and contrast. I took this overlay because of its fluid movements, like liquid, and the sparks particles to remind Clan name: Nitro. I will, of course, seek to improve the result, but I will not change it, it is in my opinion the atmosphere that I try to give to the video. The Nitro members love that overlay, I think it fit with the clan, but yeah, it needs more work.
The sun transition style needs some work in some places, I agree with that.
About the introduction, it is a clan video, every member want a good visibility of his textures and his name, I prefer to keep a long intro, like I did for Urban, even if some of you could find it boring.
About the sync... My sync is off ? I can just laugh about that, sorry.
So I will pass over and only take the constructive cristicism.
About the overlay, it is too opaque and reduces color correction and contrast. I took this overlay because of its fluid movements, like liquid, and the sparks particles to remind Clan name: Nitro. I will, of course, seek to improve the result, but I will not change it, it is in my opinion the atmosphere that I try to give to the video. The Nitro members love that overlay, I think it fit with the clan, but yeah, it needs more work.
The sun transition style needs some work in some places, I agree with that.
About the introduction, it is a clan video, every member want a good visibility of his textures and his name, I prefer to keep a long intro, like I did for Urban, even if some of you could find it boring.
About the sync... My sync is off ? I can just laugh about that, sorry.
Thanks for reactions everyone ;)
it(and every other t)t: mocucha blows off every bit of criticism
keep in mind that i had already posted in this thread respectfully and am making it more clear what's wrong, because he doesn't get it
haven't people told you enough throughout your whole experience as a video maker that your atmospheres are bad? you change the shader so many times in this video, every point the cc doesn't match it. no joke, you have all these bright shaders with cc over them that makes the joints completely different colors and a BLACK smoke overlay on top of it. in what way is that even close to being something you want to look at? it's like a kid at school wearing every color on the spectrum in one outfit and not expecting to get made fun of/any other sort of negative attention.
this is an example of GOOD atmosphere!! which you really need to see apparently
yeah, datskip used color correction like it's supposed to be used. let's look at the word first. color. correction. it's used to correct colors not change them completely. at around 2:00 ish in your video, white joints suddenly are YELLOW. in these screenshots they are still white and yet still look excellent. even the customized toris fit the atmosphere.
the overlay having some intricate meaning to the name NITRO doesn't matter nor do we, the viewers, really care for that. we are watching the video and it appears
clearly if the overlays LOOKED good then you wouldn't hear about it 3 times in your art thread.
this
does not look good.
this is how you use an overlay to make a video LOOK good, not just slapping it on top and keeping it there the whole time. (if avi was using one instead of that)
there has to be a purpose to it pertaining to that moment of the video. the purpose doesn't mean "oh hey sparks remind me of the word nitro.. XDD"
i can laugh about your sync too, especially after picking a random point in the video, and seeing the spar starting at 2:29
the replay literally just goes back and forth 3 frames or so a few times to replicate a glitchy look, which flat out doesnt cut it.
the overlay keeps going at the same pace.
the flash is near a whole second off and doesn't have anything to do with the replay, he literally kicks and after he starts landing you decide to shit out that flash on top of the video. even when the sync is timed right it's chosen poorly.
do not disregard what people say, or even flat out make fun of people for their criticism. it doesn't matter if you really agree that they're right or not because chances are a three to one opinion might as well be the right one. a video with bad shaders iced with color correction used incorrectly and topped off with a hideous overlay that makes this a genuinely ugly looking video. the editing is a completely different story, the look at all is just too much.
use any other editor as an example of what better color correction looks, because no matter how many times i've told you, you just don't seem to grasp what color correction is even for.
Last edited by TyZi; May 13, 2015 at 12:53 AM.
Originally Posted by Kaneki333
I'm Brazilian, i'm alredy fucked every day i wake up
I do actually think you're improving a little bit but your choices of overlays are still a little odd, especially the smoke one in this video
Half the time the smoke is blocking what's going on in the video, I wouldn't mind smoke being around the action but it keeps on going in front of the tori so it's a little difficult to see what's going on
If you're going for a glitchy style you should try to watch some of Moop's videos as he edits really well on glitch-hop music
I do some videos
Feel free to PM me for any video-related questions