Ehhhh I liked Version 1 better in all honestly, the holes instead of speakers kinda puts me off. I would just go with what everyone else said and make the speakers look more worn. you can put a small tear and have the fabric of the speaker kinda hand down a bit or have it seem like there speaker isn't fully attached and hang some wires out from the bottom of it like they're falling out, kinda like how you did with the eye.
Also I would support adding a crack in the red eye, could sell it a bit better.
I would probably only put tears in one speaker, as for the other remember "Time erodes color", fade the color on the speakers a bit for that feeling of age.
One more idea for you. The screws in the back panel, old tech ALWAYS ends up missing a screw. Remove one of the screws and leave the empty hole there. If thats not enough for you then you can also deform the edge missing a screw a bit.
Last edited by Kohta; Dec 10, 2015 at 10:43 AM.