OKAY
I don't feel like it but i made a promise, so here we go.
I can fly: Exceptional manipulation, very good indeed! No real flaws here.
Starting over: Ok-ish. Not really impressive, lacks solid hits and some flow. Basically, what Erth said.
Extreme: I'm really not quite sure what to say, because my opinion keeps changing (usually for the better, i'll give you that much). It's definitely a good replay, but not quite the world-shattering epiphany i'm looking for.
The last two demonstrate good control of your Tori, but tricking/dancing replays never really were my thing (meaning that i can't really rate them properly).
On the basis of me having doubts (read: my "bar" is set to "instantly blown away by awesome", which is a moderately high goal), it's a cautious no for now. HOWEVER, you're close, so don't be disheartened, and keep trying!
Edit: Same thing for xfoxyx; good replays, but not quite "instantly blown away by awesome" replays. Sorry for being a harsh judge, but we don't just seek good replay makers. We seek replay makers that both define the term "holy shit" and shove it down your throat with a gratuitous serving of garlic and bacon. For examples, just look through the higher rated replays in the Replay Makers' Replays.
Last edited by Shook; Jun 5, 2012 at 06:54 AM.