HTOTM: FUSION
Have another idea for future possible discussions:
Harvesting the organs of inmates sentenced to death
Thanks.
Death penalty

That topic is very intresting for me, as "humans" we believe everyone deserves a second chance, but what if you go too far... What if your insane...
I think anybody that's a mass murdered should die, I don't know about your opinions.

So hyde, after the topic poll, is picked is that topic gonna be discussed in a different thread, or this same, one or the topic poll.

Would we be using different threads for each topic?

Are you just arranging everything now?
Rainbowdash
Call me lLlLlLlLl because I spit straight bars when i rap or call me $tr8B@rz
il go with the death penalty as well, although i seem to remember a thread about this ages ago.
i would like to hear some justifications for it.
I'd like to point out that this is not the discussion thread. Let's not clutter this up.
Omnia Mori
sed Evici Amor
Originally Posted by RAPEZILLA View Post
That's not an insult to the members of this community in particular, just an observation that the internet is a rather poor place to hold pseudo-seminars where an anonymous person the other side of the world can claim to be a qualified authority on politics while eating microwave pizza in their underwear in mums basement.

Which leads neatly into my next point: Since there would be no validated intellectual authority leading the seminars (as a lecturer would do at university), would they be any different at all from a normal discussion topic?

I hope you will get back to me with a comprehensive answer, or perhaps simply commendation and acclaim for my brilliance, but i won't hold my breath.

This post didn't deserve an infraction, he's right. The internet is just not a good place for intelligent discussion without an authority on the topic leading the discussion (and actually able to lead it, i.e. being able to mute/kick people).
I could enter a discussion about anything and use big words, maybe even passing myself off as someone who knows what they're talking about, but in the end I'm a 16 year old kid sitting in his bedroom with no fucking clue.
'Exploration' of a subject requires prior knowledge and a good base to start from, or else people just get confused or create bullshit theories to back up other bullshit theories. You won't find many people who actually know what they're talking about here, and any discussion will end up going around in circles.
Go ahead and infract me for disagreeing with you, I don't care. Just know that your idea's bullshit and it won't work because of the way the internet (and this community, don't bother telling me off for insulting people) is.

Oh, it's generally not good practice to infract people or delete their posts just because they don't live up to your standards of quality or support your view. That's just showing that you're immature and not suited to moderation. People deserve to be able to have their say without having to worry about someone coming along and punishing them for it.
Originally Posted by lsl View Post
This post didn't deserve an infraction, he's right. The internet is just not a good place for intelligent discussion without an authority on the topic leading the discussion (and actually able to lead it, i.e. being able to mute/kick people).

I think the main problem is having someone who has no idea what is going on in control of the discussion. Giving someone who doesn't understand the power to control others is just stupid.
eg; 'Everyone knows pain is bad, we would be better off without it. Thread closed'
lolwut.

No I'm serious, that really happened.



That and people tend to degenerate pretty fast or simply not accept opposing evidence;
eg; 'I don't care what you say, you are going to hell anyway because evolution is made by the devil'


I would prefer more exploratory and less binary arguments.
So none of this "Death Penalty, right or wrong?"; instead: "How to punish people?". Then people can suggest DP, or DP (the other DP...), or whatever other kind of punishment or system. People are encouraged to find other solutions, rather than just repeating "KILLING BAD PEOPLE IS GOOD".

Eg of a good topic; "How will technology have advanced in the far future, what is the end-game?"
When I see you, my heart goes DOKI⑨DOKI
Fish: "Gorman has been chosen for admin. After a lengthy discussion we've all decided that Gorman is the best choice for the next admin."
Originally Posted by lsl View Post
This post didn't deserve an infraction, he's right. The internet is just not a good place for intelligent discussion without an authority on the topic leading the discussion (and actually able to lead it, i.e. being able to mute/kick people).
I could enter a discussion about anything and use big words, maybe even passing myself off as someone who knows what they're talking about, but in the end I'm a 16 year old kid sitting in his bedroom with no fucking clue.
'Exploration' of a subject requires prior knowledge and a good base to start from, or else people just get confused or create bullshit theories to back up other bullshit theories. You won't find many people who actually know what they're talking about here, and any discussion will end up going around in circles.
Go ahead and infract me for disagreeing with you, I don't care. Just know that your idea's bullshit and it won't work because of the way the internet (and this community, don't bother telling me off for insulting people) is.

Oh, it's generally not good practice to infract people or delete their posts just because they don't live up to your standards of quality or support your view. That's just showing that you're immature and not suited to moderation. People deserve to be able to have their say without having to worry about someone coming along and punishing them for it.

That was harl, banning him is sport.

Prior knowledge will be attributed through articles.
Hoss.
I think seminars are a great Idea.

I also think that it's pretty obvious who is skilled in a topic and who is not, but maybe that's just me.

I'm used to /b/, so Maybe it's an acquired skill.

I might regret that I said that later...
Last edited by PlasmaNova; Jan 12, 2011 at 10:06 PM.
Co-Leader of The Brotherhood of Steel
the future of toribash