I agree with this statement.. Some parts when you are on the building and the fast zombies were crawling up the pipes and you heard a clinking noise.. but didn't know what it was.. and BAM.. scare the shit out of me sometimes.

I have never, ever beaten a Resident Evil game. And not because of lack of ability. D:

Never have beaten Obscure either for the same reason.

I feel so fail because of that -_-

The scariest game I played is Silent Hill for sure. Sometimes I had enough of that blood covered walls. I also figured quiet late that when it's dark the monsters are everywhere and where is light there aren't so many monsters. The game was cool.

I call System Shock 2.

F.E.A.R or Penumbra, aint really sure.

Clocktower.

The one for the PSOne scared me (bleep)less SOMANY times...

The one for the SNES was worse. In terms of being scary, I mean. :x

with the texture improvements ! yea that was pretty scary darn scary, other than that...i gotta go with F.E.A.R.....if you got a good surround sound system it'll make you shit your pants

Sanity's requiem was amusing.
Innovative, etc.
Resident Evil 4 had some parts that could have been pretty damn scary, but they failed miserably.
Again.

I have never been scared by a game, and have played most of the games you guys already listed.

I will say that the game that came closest to being scary was F.E.A.R. It was kind of creepy at parts.

The scariest game I played?



The maze game