So TMinster, you're not that bad but I see many useless movement for your first and your third replay, so your movement looked so twitchy. On your third replay, you change your move direction(frame 510) and it was quite weird. Actually from what i see, from all your replays, it was alright, the hits were nice even it lacked of aim.
Try to get better at your movement, make it smoother and make the general look better. Try to aim your hit better too.
So no from me.
For Osiris,
Well, for your first replay, it was simple but it was good. The opener was a bit stiff but the manip overall was quite enjoyable and nice, your movement looked quite smooth and that's good. Boom was also nice in my opinion.
For your second replay, it wasn't as good as your first, the opener was alright but then you ghosted your arm make it looked weird. The boom wasn't that good, didin't look solid for me. It will be good if you throw the head to uke and make dm with it, it will be more better than you did. The skeet was pretty slow and wasn't look good.
And for your last, the opener was nothing special, the beginning fo the replay looked weird and you ghosted your hand again, looked ugly. It wasn't interesting until you moved at frame 1340. Your body in the air should be smoother a bit, contracted your knee like that make it looked bad. Decap was pretty bad, it lacked of aim.
So overall you're pretty much alright, but I'm afraid you're not quite there yet, sorry but it's a no