Rfifan, I'm going to have to say no
the first too replay were extremely simplistic, although the first one was pretty cool. I enjoyed the fact you ghosted his entire torso for the most part, but other than that, it wasn't anything extraordinarily awesome.
The last one was more on top of it, and if you posted more of those, it might sway my mind again, but even that one had plenty of flaws.
It contained awesome, which I enjoyed. The hits were pretty spot on, and they looked powerful . Although, the ending glute kick sorta ruined it for me, the kick-off with the right leg, into contracting for the initial kick on the glutes looked too sudden and didn't look at that well.
You also forced the pose by extending your hip/knee to position you, and that also, to me, looked pretty bad, ruined the overall flow of what was happening. Looked rather twitchy.
plus, floaty/long openers displease me, I was wasting 100ish frames of watching nothing
overall, it's a no. Comeback in a few weeks
-----------------------------
duck, you have a lot of speed, and I enjoy that. But you twitch a lot, like in the first replay, more towards the end of it. You were extremely stiff as well. The hits were fast, and looked rather cool, although you ruined that when you hit your head. The flip thing was extremely stiff, and you twitched quite a bit while doing it
second replay was extremely weird, the opener was different, the group flailing around wasn't pleasing to me, it was just like a "kick this way so I can go to uke" kind of movement, and didn't really have any initial point to it, or so it looked like to me. The hits were, again, good and fast. Which I still enjoy, but the movements for everything were rather stiff and unappealing.
The last replay seemed pointless to me. You ripped your head off, cool. But you didn't do anything with it, which kind of threw me off and led me down a deep dark ally with nothing at the end of it. I was expecting some sort of voodoo, but I didn't get anything. Just a basic replay with your head off. And again, stiffer than a mofo
so, with that being said, it's a no for you as well. You have speed, and your hits are pretty solid, but you need to clean your replays up a bit. Try not to hit your head, etc. Try not to be so stiff in your replays and relax it up a bit for a little more power under the hood. Try again in a few weeks as well.
----------------
I got them covered j, unless you have a different opinion/want to add on.