Secret Santa 2024
Originally Posted by nerti View Post
Are you serious? Do you seriously think this would help?
"This the best joke I've heard all week".

Of course it would help. Who would go around killing innocent people in the name of Islam if there were nobody in the West who'd give a crap about Mohammad or the so-called "caliph" of ISIS? If there are no Muslims to be "radicalized", you can rest easy knowing that your drawings of some fictional character won't get you a bowl of lead for breakfast.

Send them all home, let them deal with their own bad breed, and once they are ready to accept that living in a foreign country means accepting the norms of that country and not forcing your own values on your hosts, then maybe let them visit every once in a while.


The probability of this happening is 0, I know. This incident will probably be forgotten when the next sensation comes around, and we'll all go back to living carefree while our enemies are living right next door.
Why do you still have that opinion? We've already gone over it and pointed out that it's stupid, so don't continue to have this stupid opinion.
You may have gone over it and decided in your head that it's stupid, but that doesn't make it stupid.
It's straightforward. It's never going to happen, but I'd sell a liver to see it done.

Did you know that there are political parties all over Europe going by this idea? And each time stuff like this happens, they'll have more voters. Maybe do it enough times and they'll go ahead and go through with it.

Actually, it's pretty mild compared to those who'd just re-open Auschwitz for our lovely guests. Radicalization goes both ways.
Last edited by ynvaser; Jan 9, 2015 at 07:58 AM.
Originally Posted by ynvaser View Post
You may have gone over it and decided in your head that it's stupid, but that doesn't make it stupid.

Originally Posted by Ele View Post
I can't think of a better way to increase tension, inspire more radicals and completely fuck up relations with the East, than persecuting ALL arabs.

Until you tell me how deporting all arabs won't result in what I said, then it's a stupid idea.

Originally Posted by Ele View Post
It's straightforward. It's never going to happen, but I'd sell a liver to see it done.

It's ridiculous, juvenile and myopic.
Last edited by Ele; Jan 9, 2015 at 08:00 AM.
Originally Posted by Ele View Post
Until you tell me how deporting all arabs won't result in what I said, then it's a stupid idea.

Okay, I'll try to go over it for you.
We, the EU, aren't as dependent on Arab oil imports as the US is, with only around 15% of our imports coming from the Middle East. Unemployment of nationals is growing due to immigrants taking up unskilled jobs, which is quite notable in Britain which is considering leaving the EU so it could introduce harsher immigration laws.
Yes, it might piss some people off, but we could cooperate more with Russia and it's satellite states to make up for our economical hit, or perhaps look for alternate sources of power like you said yourself.

We don't need the Middle East. Even if we did, we have the military capacity to carve out a piece if needed.

But then again, we are too liberal to do this. If someone blew up the Reichstag or the Eiffel Tower, we'd probably hold a minute of silence and blame the individual attackers, not what they represent.
Last edited by ynvaser; Jan 9, 2015 at 08:12 AM.
You didn't answer any of my concerns in that post ("increase tension, inspire more radicals and completely fuck up relations with the East") except by saying 'fuck the Middle East, we don't need them'.

Your opinion is thus still stupid.
I hate to spam, but maybe your concerns are stupid. Redundant, don't hurt me.

EDIT: I'll try to make this less spammy. Nobody trades with North Korea except China. Is it fine to say screw them, but not other countries?
Please tell me how my concerns are stupid. I'm begging you.

NK isn't relevant to this discussion. We're not talking about NK terrorists or deporting Koreans.
Last edited by Ele; Jan 9, 2015 at 08:27 AM.
It was an example regarding screwing people. You don't like their government so you condemn their civilians to starvation. We don't like Muslim extremists, but we are trying to cherry-pick the bad guys for some reason which obviously isn't working.

If I were an Arab living in Europe, and I'd have to leave because of my people's predominant religion's extremists, I'd be more pissed at said extremists than my hosts.

You know, just because you don't like my answer doesn't make it stupid or insufficient. I addressed all your concerns by saying that they are of negligible importance. I took the time to answer your post in detail, so I find it quite disrespectful that you dismiss me and my opinion this way. I don't think this behaviour has a place in this subforum.
Kthx.
Last edited by ynvaser; Jan 9, 2015 at 08:41 AM.
Originally Posted by ynvaser View Post
You know, just because you don't like my answer doesn't make it stupid or insufficient. I addressed all your concerns by saying that they are of negligible importance. I took the time to answer your post in detail, so I find it quite disrespectful that you dismiss me and my opinion this way. I don't think this behaviour has a place in this subforum.

You did not explain how persecuting all arabs, resulting in increased tension, more radicals and hostile relations with the East is not important.

Your solution does all those things (which you admit, seeing as you're just saying they're not important). Your solution is clearly a bad idea.

I'm not being disrespectful. You didn't address my points 'in detail' at all.