I know I'm in no position to comment or judge on this...but I don't think an exception should be made if a rank 1 member and a rank 2 member say that they "like him". It's not like they have a position to say yes or get him in... And about the promise to loyal and active. Didn't all members make that? You know, the ones that clan hopped, the ones that we added to clan enemies, the ones that we kicked for inactivity?