Originally Posted by
T0ribush
May I remind that Jimi has probably never played the solo exactly like that again. All of his solos live are pretty improvised. Also If I were to do that solo I would do it in my own way. I wouldn't want to intentionally sound like another guitarist.
No, I'm not amazed by shredders. I like the sound that a lot of them have. Sounding fast and doing fast solos isn't really that hard, but you have to know how many times they hit a note and for solos with an insane amount of rhythm sound cool.
If you have mastered playing fast you must have mastered playing slow or slower than regular shredding tempo.
If you also played a live show fast without a mistake then that's like what the fuck, man.
bolded phrases are where i disagree.
Being able to sound like other guitarists is critical to getting better. Blindly stumbling around in the dark playing random notes until you develop your own style is a load of crap. No great player ever did that. The greats of today stand on the shoulders of the greats from the past. You take the best that has gone before and then, only once you understand that, do you put your own touch into it. I know a guitarist who plays a lot of hendrix, and comes up with these incredible fills and instrumentals out of nowhere, which kick the hell outta mine and stay true to the spirit of the original song at the same time - so i asked him how he does it, and guess what. He learns the tracks note for note as hendrix played them on his best take, to the point where he can pull out a carbon copy of the track, and THEN he plays them his own way - sounds a lot more awesome than the guys who pretend that they can come up with their own version without even knowing the original.
tl;dr you can't improve on a song and do a quality version of your own without knowing the original - the better you know it, the better your own version will be.
And the rest -
Shredding fast and doing fast solo's isn't easy at all. Just because playing a slow solo that really captures your audience is incredibly difficult it doesn't make the other stuff easy at all. Knowing how to play fast is a very useful skill to get that 'wow' factor into your playing, but it has to be used properly (take gary moore as an excellent example of a player who knows how and when to play fast, and dragonforce as an example of a band that doesn't understand how to use speed properly).
The third bolded phrase was the most wrong for a couple of reasons. 1- you play differently when you play fast and when you play at regular tempo - your pick attack changes a lot, and you don't mess about with vibrato. As well as this, most fast players use a lot of compression and distortion, which makes playing with dynamics impossible. When i talk about playing slow, i don't mean the way you play slow when you practice something to play it faster, i'm talking about playing at a deliberately slow pace. Sure it's easier to get the notes out, but past absolute beginner level there's a lot more to playing than that.