Its a lil mis-mapped, try to tighten the oval up make it much smaller and pull the heas gear symbol down a bit.
Oh and with the drop shadow you have on the symbol, I feel like it would look better if it was straight down, not at an angle. Cause Imean its toribash, when are you ever gonna have angular light (minus the shaders ofc)
And now for my own suggestion.
I think we should have:
YES
ACCEPTED
NO
DENIED
Stamps for the recruitment thread, I've seen em around, they look clean and make our decisions appear more official