Secret Santa 2024
I think what she does is her choice, and it's better to have abortion clinics and such to do it properly for her so she doesn't try it herself and hurt herself. It's her choice, I'd hate to be forced into a huge commitment like a child when I'm not ready, it'd fuck a lot of shit up in their lives IMO.
Originally Posted by sireal View Post
I think what she does is her choice, and it's better to have abortion clinics and such to do it properly for her so she doesn't try it herself and hurt herself. It's her choice, I'd hate to be forced into a huge commitment like a child when I'm not ready, it'd fuck a lot of shit up in their lives IMO.

Originally Posted by RayA75 View Post
How can you justify that?
In my mind, objective functions such as life much outweigh the subjective goals that any one person has, such as happiness or convenience.

I'd like to emphasize this.
Mei fati dominus, mei animi dux
Need to PM a SMod?

Unofficial Skimmer of Discussion!

Fabula Magnus wants more able RPers!
Cataclysm is still alive?


Thorn


Wiggi must love me forever now.
Say your working a fulltime job, already have 2 kids and your husband's fucked off. You're completely full blown the whole time, with almost no time to relax. You're not getting paid enough for the work you're doing and you can barely afford food for your family. You go out on your off day and have some fun, ends up being a one night stand. Except you forgot to use protection and you're pregnant now.

What's better, having a child that will not be able to eat enough food, and can't be taken care of most of the time, or having an abortion to momentarily fix your mistake.

If you know you can't have a proper environment for a child to live in - food to eat, clothes, taken care of, then I think you should be able to choose whether you have this child or not.
I see what you mean and sympathize with anyone in such a situation.

Though, abortion still is not an ethical "fix" to such situations. The means does not justify the ends. This is to say the the means of abortion, as unethical as I have demonstrated, do not justify the end of happiness. This is still the argument in question, and I believe the logic itself proves it.

Again, staying away from that abortion is murder argument, does an act that infringes on the right to become ( and subsequently life) justify an end that satisfies that right to happiness?
My answer is no because becoming (and subsequently life) is the foundation upon which happiness is sought. We cannot have happiness without life, and we cannot have life without first becoming.
Mei fati dominus, mei animi dux
Need to PM a SMod?

Unofficial Skimmer of Discussion!

Fabula Magnus wants more able RPers!
Cataclysm is still alive?


Thorn


Wiggi must love me forever now.
I think it is mate. It's their choice to have a child or not, that's a fact. The rights of the living outweigh the rights of the possibly could be living. It COULD live, but it's not. It's only a possibility, could be stillborn, could be anything.

What about rape victims? What do you do in that situation?

Abortion is ethical in my view.
With rape victims, the other side of the argument is more traumatic. The trauma to the mother, her culpability and such should be taken into account. It is more understandable. Allow me to link you to my argument against abortion, possibly you will understand my position moreso after seeing it.
http://forum.toribash.com/showpost.p...49&postcount=8
Mei fati dominus, mei animi dux
Need to PM a SMod?

Unofficial Skimmer of Discussion!

Fabula Magnus wants more able RPers!
Cataclysm is still alive?


Thorn


Wiggi must love me forever now.
Indeed, you make valid points. However your proposal of case-by-case studies is probably going to cause more problems, consistency wise - "why did she get allowed and I didn't?".

Also, if you have a fertalised egg, it's not certain that it will form into a human, stillborn and such, so you can't definitely be certain that the fetus would be alive at all, so abortion would not stop it's right to live.
Originally Posted by sireal View Post
Indeed, you make valid points. However your proposal of case-by-case studies is probably going to cause more problems, consistency wise - "why did she get allowed and I didn't?".

Sure. That is definitely a possibility. Does it make abortion unethical? No.
What it does deal with is the legality of abortion. I feel that abortion should be regulated and used in cases when it is the only alternative left.

Also, if you have a fertalised egg, it's not certain that it will form into a human, stillborn and such, so you can't definitely be certain that the fetus would be alive at all, so abortion would not stop it's right to live.

No, it isn't certain. Here's a quote from a post earlier in the thread that I think applies quite well.

Originally Posted by RayA75 View Post
I also must note that there is a difference in antecedent states prior to fetal development, and fetal development. A sperm is in the process of being a sperm, like I said so many times before. We should also note that a sperm, being a gamete, has the potentiality to have life. A fetus can also be said to be only being a fetus, but a fetus is becoming a human, no matter the potentiality. By that I mean, there doesn't have to be another requirement for life. A fetus is a self sufficient state for life.

Mei fati dominus, mei animi dux
Need to PM a SMod?

Unofficial Skimmer of Discussion!

Fabula Magnus wants more able RPers!
Cataclysm is still alive?


Thorn


Wiggi must love me forever now.
See, I'm going to be very blunt. Abortion, ethical or not, is the choice of the woman carrying the baby. The government/etc is nobody to tell you what to do with your body. Personally, I think using a condom solves a lot of problems...but in case amniocentesis is preformed, and a disorder is detected, abortion should be an option for her and her family.
<Jaker> fucking yes , the black anal fetish fetus , :-* love ya .. btw i love how your teehts are touching my *PIEP* when you do a blowjob <3
I LOVE YOU :-*
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Leader of [l]|ORMO Recruiter|BISH|[WTU]|[ETC]|Replays|[TGS]|