only thing i found slightly scary about dead island when you like start to open a door then a infected runs at you, or when you like looting shit and you turn around. infected in your face.
First of all, I get through Amnesia and dead space fine, but I shit my pants in bioshock.
NO. Amnesia made me have nightmares man. Dead Space was also a horrible experience. Though, it was fun. Bioshock wasn't so scary for me. just some parts... BUT NOTHING BEATS THE FEAR AMNESIA GAVE ME ._____. it was sooo fuckin insane.