The flame forge is inaccurate. When in the forge I made a very specific flame and it looked great. After I had clicked to buy it and test it out it for real it was suddenly different.
I know for a fact that something happened in the process of me buying it because I checked the settings over and over and tested it in freeplay many times before buying.

If you need some sort of proof I could show an admin or whatever in game, I don't really know if my flame can be fixed now but it really isn't what I payed a shit load of money for.

:C

What version of the game are you using? Things have changed a few times since the forge was made, so using outdated clients may cause problems.

3.85.

Definitely worth an update.

The latest is here:
http://www.toribash.com/Toribash-3.88-Setup.exe

But since there's a few bugs you can get a previous version here:
http://www.toribash.com/Toribash-3.86-Setup.exe

Edit:
Downloading the new version of Toribash didn't change my current flame and it also didn't change the flame forge settings.
I put in the exact same settings from before and it looked like how I wanted it to previously even though after being forged it did not come out that way. The version is not the problem, I'm fairly sure it is the forger itself.

Update - Discussing in PM.