Please. Quit making these threads. I'm begging you. Every time another one pops up I am physically pained. Just please, stop it.
And anyway, as far as the shovel thing is concerned, people have different definitions of a shovel. My definition is a double hip grab and lift.
There are also idiots that bitch and moan about people lifting and pushing AT ALL, even if it is using hand grabs. Those people try to say that if you don't kick in aikido you're a nub shoveler. That's ridiculous though, because pushing can be countered at any time if a player is good enough. Just because you lift somebody into the air and push them out doesn't mean you are shoveling them.