Red Dead Redemption vs Grand Theft Auto IV.

There both made by Rockstar.
They both are open sandbox games.

Vote now intill March the 1st and we will see which is better.

(If its Red Dead or GTA put your reason why, must be a full sentence long)
*b ounce*

There was a thread, like a week ago, that asked for opinions on Halo v.s CoD, which was closed pretty swiftly. I don't think this one will last long, either.

Anyway. I haven't played Red Dead, but I can say that I really don't like GTA4, especially it's story.

RDR for story. GTA 4 for gameplay, fun, etc.

Both un-comparable games.

No X vs. Z threads kthx.