are they ?

For a good video, no.

I think the 2nd replay can pass but not the first.The running could be better

The first one may pass with some effects
the 2nd one is bad , I don't understand your style , first you do some noob moves then you suddenly go "oh look lets try some realism " , that doesn't work buddy.

Kat : yeah i now , i tried to do mad man , i saw a tut about mad manning and i failed epicly in doing it , im much better in spars
cuddle : yeh i know , i was just trying my new run , it sorta hard to make one so i just tost some random things together