Um, I know I'm not in SMOOTH, but I hope my opinion counts. If you've ever looked at his post history, he's failed at least 5 threads, and about 3 clan creation threads. The clan threads were all posted in the wrong place, or didn't follow the rules because he didn't read the stickies.
Now, for in-game. He was highly annoying in our server. We warned him a few times to cut it out, but it was to no avail. So we banned him. When that ban ran out, he came back in and started yelling at us in caps, until I had to kick him and ban again.
Just my opinion on this guy.