was good?

Eh the thumb is a little weird it looks like he twisted his thumb to the left lol but everything this else is good.

Pencil drawings need directional shading to create depth.
youve traced the shape of the hand well enough, but your shading has no depth.
your pencil lines should show the curve of the skin.

look how this person curves his pencil line to create depth.
apply the same thing to your own drawings.

Wrist seems too thin in comparison to the hand.

And like suplexes said, the thumb seems a little twisted.

yeah the whole hand looks a bit off, just keep practicing anatomy. Shading doesn't look that bad to be honest.
Here is a handy tut http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUbt1l4tBJg

Nice, but the overall hand is a little bit off, like the shape is just a little wierd in some places :/