All the replays were from SkyWhales replay thread. This is my frist edit ever I would say the song is pretty terrible but i got lazy looking for one.

Software: AfterEffects

a lot better than most peoples first edit, just keep going how you are, experiment with effects and you'll be fine

congratulations, you managed to opt HUD, use decent shaders, and actually attempt free am/sync.

try looking up sync tutorials on YouTube, I'm pretty sure I saw you take like a little swing at it somewhere around there

that's fine, it is much better than the norm here

Good first video. The camera is good (a bit rough at 17), it is clean and cool. Try to put some effects ?

Thanks for all the CnC guys. I have posted 2 more. With these first videos I'm not going for any big effects I'm trying to get down the basics first but I think I'm ready to make it more flashy on my next one!

Nice smooth camera strokes. You used the replays well with the music. I actually liked the minimal effects, it was smooth and simplistic, but it worked really well. You're already better than many video makers in my opinion.

And dayum, what a good replay maker XD

not bad for a first edit

i'm not going to repeat what others said here, although some people don't like it when editors use trails.

i dunno why dont ask me, just a head sup

Trails generally don't look nice if you speed clips up, they just become something of a waste of pixels. You can't tell what they are at higher speeds, and when you slow-mo, they look pretty horrendous. It's only if your keeping your clip at a level speed that they look alright.

P good, better then plenty of people's first edits. Keep working