I'm sorry for not commenting this thread earlier (after all I've commented pretty much all of the other threads on the first page), but I don't usually comment MP.
it's very hard to rate since you didn't see the match actually happening and hence risk seriously conflicting the poster's own opinion on the replay and/or over(/under)rating the replay.
why I'm telling you this is because it's probably the reason for the quietness on your thread, not only from me.